The assignment
You are asked to write an which answers the following
question:
Should participants ever be deceived concerning the true
nature of a psychological experiment in which they are taking
part?
Your essay should be based on your reading and the discussions that have taken place on this module.
The marking criteria for the essay are provided on pages 6-7. The main criterion of the essay is that you answer the question. We want you to provide a focussed and balanced answer to the question above. You should think about the material introduced in Lectures 3 and 4 and read the guidance on ethical conduct provided by the BPS and/or APA. In addition, have a look at some of the resources provided in this document (see pages 2-4). These sources will provide you with some ideas and information that will be helpful when writing the essay.
Hints and tips
Below are links to several papers that discuss the use of deception in psychological
research. You should read some of these articles and decide whether you think
researchers should use deception. Once you have decided on your point of view,
4PS003 Assignment 1
2
you can use the rest of the essay to justify your answer. You will need to provide a
balanced argument, and to do this you must highlight points that both support and
contradict your answer. But one side of the argument, in your opinion, should be
stronger than the other. Your job is to show why this is the case.
There is no right or wrong answer, but you will need to engage in some selfreflection
in order to make a decision. This is a starting point of your continued selfreflection
concerning ethical approaches to research, as well as the first essay you
will be writing on your degree programme. Since you are at the beginning of your
degree, we see this assignment as an invaluable skills-building exercise. Indeed,
one of the key skills that you will need to develop throughout your degree is the
ability to form a well-balanced argument. This is the skill that is being most keenly
observed in this piece of assessment.
Other information
We ask that you provide a full references list at the end of your essay, in APA format.
Of course, we are also aware that you will be new to referencing, so this will not
affect your overall mark. It is just a useful way of getting some feedback on your
referencing prior to subsequent assignments in which you will be required to use
APA referencing properly.
You should also write your essay in the third person – avoiding first person pronouns
such as “I” or “my”. Again though, this will not unduly influence your mark on this
assignment.
Resources
This list is by no means exhaustive, but it provides references to some articles that
you might find helpful when tackling this assignment. You can also use the
references list from Lecture 4 and academic databases to find other relevant
sources.
Controversial studies that have used deception
Below are references to some studies that made controversial use of deception. You
may want to comment on some of these in your essay, but there are plenty of other
examples that you can discuss. Remember, this is not an essay on Milgram, nor is it
an essay where you extensively discuss the classic studies. Here, you should
critique and answer the question at hand.
Asch, S. (1955). Opinions and social pressure. Scientific American, 193, 31-35.
In a famous study examining the effects of group pressure, volunteers were told to
judge the length of lines in groups of 7 to 9. Unbeknownst to the actual participant,
the other members of the group were confederates who deliberately gave an
incorrect answer.
Bramel, D. (1963). Selection of a target for defensive projection. Journal of Abnormal
and Social Psychology, 66, 318-324.
4PS003 Assignment 1
3
Heterosexual males were given discrepant information about their sexuality.
Specifically, they were deceived into thinking they were sexually aroused by photos
depicting other men.
This paper is available on the 4PS003 Canvas topic.
Campbell, D., Sanderson, R. E., & Laverty, S. G. (1964). Characteristics of a
conditioned response in human subjects during extinction trials following a single
traumatic conditioning trial. Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 68, 627-
639.
Alcoholic participants thought they were taking part in an experiment testing a
possible treatment for alcoholism, but without their knowledge they were injected
with a drug that caused a temporary interruption to their respiration. The effects of
this drug were described as “horrific” (p. 627) and led participants to feel they were
dying.
Milgram, S. (1963). Behavioral study of obedience. Journal of Abnormal and Social
Psychology, 67, 371-378.
A famous and controversial study in which participants believed they were
administering intense and potentially fatal electric shocks to another participant.
Papers discussing deception in (psychological) research
The references below provide insightful reviews of the use of deception in
psychology, whether it is ethical, and the advantages and disadvantages of
deceiving participants. They may provide you with some ideas to discuss in your
essay. Hyperlinks to the original sources are provided.
Epley, N., & Huff, C. (1998). Suspicion, affective response, and educational benefit
as a result of deception in psychology research. Personality and Social Psychology
Bulletin, 24, 759-768.
Hertwig, R., & Ortmann, A. (2008a). Deception in experiments: Revisiting the
arguments in its defense. Ethics & Behavior, 18, 59-92.
Hertwig, R., & Ortmann, A. (2008b). Deception in social psychological experiments:
Two misconceptions and a research agenda. Social Psychology Quarterly, 71, 222-
227.
Kimmel, A. J. (2011). Deception in psychological research – a necessary evil? The
Psychologist, 24, 580-585.
Uz, I., & Kemmelmeier, M. (2017). Can deception be desirable? Social Science
Information, 56, 98-106.